Module 2 Topic A:

Power, Sport, and Masculinities

This topic focuses on the introducing the relationship between physical culture and the socio-culturally constructed, and performative nature, of gender and gender difference.  This leads to an examination of the hyper-masculine orientation of contemporary sport culture, with specific attention paid to the various ways that involvement with sport/physical activity contributes to the embodied performance and normalization of traditional understandings of masculinity.

1. LECTURE

For six slides per page format (for printing) click : HERE

For one slide per page format (for viewing on computer) click: HERE

2. VIDEO CLIPS

These video clips, unless otherwise advised, will be shown during lecture.  They are made available here for revision purposes.

Video Clip 1:  Judith Butler (2011) speaking on issues related to gender performance and performativity.

Video Clip 2: The rousing half-time speech at a minor league Australian Rules football game (WARNING: Bad Language alert!).

Video Clip 3: A clip from The IT Crowd, demonstrating the learned nature of masculine performance, particularly related to sport spectating.

Video Clip 4:  “I’m Good” Pepsi Max commercial, illustrating the performative nature of masculinity.

Video Clip 5: MTV feature on the development of the instrumental football body.

Video Clip 6: MTV feature on the development of the professional oriented bodybuilder’s body.

Video Clip 7: The Tough Guy Race, more examples of performative masculinities.

Video Clip 8: Promotion for an UFC computer game, illustrating the commercial media’s representation of violent masculinity.

Video Clip 9: MTV feature on the development of the cosmetically manufactured body (WARNING: Surgical procedure alert!).

Video Clip 10: An excerpt from an episode of Frasier, highlighting the changed relationship between the exercising body and sexuality.

Video Clip 11: An excerpt from the movie Murderball, and the performance of masculinity by those with physically-challenged bodies.

3. REQUIRED READINGS

It is expected that you will complete these readings prior to the discussion sections, and that–where appropriate–your engage them within your classroom discussion.

Reading I: Messner, M. (2002). Playing Center: The Triad of Violence. In Men’s Sports Taking the field: Women, men, and sports (pp. 27-61). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Reading II: Simpson, C. (2013, February 27). How long can the NFL get away with asking players if they’re gay? Theatlanticwire.com.

Reading III: Waldron, T. (2013, April 30). Jason Collins, Brittany Griner, and Sexuality and Masculinity in Men’s and Women’s Sport. Thinkprogress.com/sports.

4. THEMATIC REVIEW QUESTIONS

Given the volume of information provided in the classroom, you are strongly advised not to engage the material solely during lectures.

Rather, you are strongly encouraged to review each theme carefully on your own, following which you should test your knowledge and understanding by answering the Thematic Review Questions which can be accessed HERE.

5. KEY CONCEPTS

The following key concepts represent the core knowledge related to this topic, and you should ensure that you develop a thorough knowledge and understanding of them before moving on to the next topic:


De-Naturalizing the Gendered/Sexed Body


The Social and Cultural Construction of the Body


Sex and Gender Classifications


Gender Performance and Performativity


The Hierarchical Gender Binary


Patriarchy and Patriarchal Institutions


The Corporeal Origins of Patriarchy


Sport as a Performative Gendered and Gendering Institution


The Embodied Bases of Masculinity


The Social and Cultural Construction of the Sporting/Active Body


Gendered Sporting Ideologies, Institutions, Practices, and Texts


The Hyper-Masculine Centre of American Sport Culture


Physicality and Masculinity


The Primary Sources of Masculinity


The Demands of Hyper-Masculine Sport Performance


The Triad of Sport-Related Violence


Sport, Masculinity, and the Fear of Social Rejection


Sport and Hegemonic Masculinity


The Process and Practice of Mosaic Masculinity


Instrumental, Professional, Exercising, and Representative Masculinities


The Homosexual and Able-Bodies Centres of Masculine Sport Culture


Emergent Sporting Masculinities


Cosmetic, Homosexual, and Adaptive Masculinities

6. DISCUSSION QUESTION/TASK #5


This question/task will be discussed in discussion sections on:

Monday, October 22

Wednesday, October 24


Men’s involvement in organized sport is both detrimental to themselves, to their immediate social relations, and to society more generally.  As such, organized sport is in serious need of reform.  Discuss this observation and any reform strategies you feel appropriate.

7. ESSAY QUESTION #5 (this is an option for the Module 2 essay)


According to Judith Butler (1995, p. 25, “There is not gender identity behind the expressions of gender;...identity is performatively constituted by the very ‘expressions’ that are said to be its results.”

Discuss the relevance of Butler’s observation for the understanding of the embodiment, experiencing, and effects of masculine performativity within sport and physical culture. 

This essay should be a minimum of 1,500 words to answer it comprehensively.


You may find the following academic sources useful in completing this assignment.  You do not have to use these sources, they are simply provided for you as an introduction to the literature, and you should use them where appropriate and/or relevant. Also, be warned, these readings do not count towards the THREE additional academic sources you are expected to use within your essays (however, they may direct you toward additional academic sources you could use).

Chimot, C., & Louveau, C. (2010). Becoming a man while playing a female sport: The construction of masculine identity in boys doing rhythmic gymnastics. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 45(4), 436-456.

Coles, T. (2008).  Finding the space in the field of masculinity: Lived experiences of men’s masculinities.  Journal of Sociology, 44 (3), 233-248.

Gill, R., Henwood, K., & McLean, C. (2005). Body projects and the regulation of normative masculinity. Body and Society, 11(1), 37-62.

Wellard, I. (2002). Men, sport, body performance and the maintenance of 'exclusive masculinity'. Leisure Studies, 21(3-4), 235-248.

If you choose to complete this essay, and in addition to the sources provided on this page, you need to identify and use (either through paraphrasing or direct quotation) interpretations, insights, or information from a MINIMUM OF THREE appropriate academic sources (in addition to those provided for you on this website).

The deadline for submitting your Module II Essay is before class on Sunday November 23.  In order to receive feedback from your TA, you can submit a draft version of your essay up to and including Sunday November 16.


Important: The ELMS/Canvas website will not accept essays after the due time and date.

Be sure to review the details on the module essay page.   On that page you will find the EVALUATION CRITERIA for module essays (which you are strongly encouraged to read), you will also find links to the appropriate academic sources you should use when researching and writing your module essays, and the style and format guidelines you need to follow when completing module essays.  All this information needs to be read, understood, and closely followed for you to succeed in this course.